Blog Entry

Joe Torre is OVERATED

Posted on: November 12, 2008 8:01 am

Sure he's a decent manager. Sure he's a nice guy, but he is highly overrated. Look at what he did when he managed the Mets, Braves, and St. Louis. He managed the Mets for 5 seasons and hovered around a .400 winning percentage(bottom of the division). He inhereted a good Braves team and the winning percentage dropped each year he was there and managed the Cardinals to a below .500 winning percentage(.478) over 6 years( he leaves after they finished in 4th place in the division and then they win the division the next year with La Russa).

Then he manages a Yankee team with the highest payroll in MLB in a then weak division and gets a winning percentage. Then the Red Sox became competitive and raise their payroll , no more WS Wins. sure the Yanks got into the playoffs, but lost in the first round '05-'07. I could have managed that team into the playoffs with that talent.

Another fact: What is the ONLY team ever, in any of the major sports, to have a 3-0 lead in a playoff series and lose? yes, that's right. The Joe Torre managed Yankees

How does a team with that payroll/talent not make it into the WS? The Yankees wondered the same thing which explains their "insult"ing contract offer with incentive bonuses for each round totaling $5 MM per year for 3 years. "INSULT"? maybe the yanks should have just fired Torre.

The Dodgers got into the playoff due to a weak division. the Dodgers had a below .500 record before Manny comes over and then they win the division with a weak record and the Diamondbacks losing the lead. For most of the year there were 12-13 teams in MLB that had records that would have been in first in the NL West. How are Torre's moves paying off in the NLCS this year? not too good.



The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or